Xbox has been losing to PlayStation for two console generations, creating an environment where Sony is on top and is barely touched by any console competition. Some might say that Nintendo is competing via their Switch lineup, but many think of them as operating in their own lane/niche. For console gaming to be healthy, we need Xbox to be healthy enough to compete with PlayStation. What can Xbox do to claw back some market share? Are Xbox exclusive games a viable way back?
Xbox has been losing to PlayStation for two generations now. In this latest duel, the PlayStation 5 has completely eclipsed the Xbox Series consoles in sales - despite Microsoft employing some very consumer friendly tactics including: Xbox Game Pass, a more affordable hardware tier, and releasing many of their games across platforms. For virtually the first time, PlayStation gamers can enjoy the majority of what the Xbox has to offer in terms of exclusives with Microsoft’s cross-platform policy… but is that consumer-friendly tactic contributing to their undoing. Without console exclusives, why would anyone bother buying an Xbox?
In this edition of the Web News, Matt and Mike discuss what Microsoft needs to do to try and gain back some ground against PlayStation, whether console exclusives are a good thing, and if the recent leadership change (and a couple of console exclusive game announcements) are enough to turn the tide.
This transcript is machine generated, there may be errors.
Matt: [00:00:00] All righty, everybody. This is yet another edition of the Web News, and today we're talking some tech. We're talking some gaming tech. Now, we're not gonna be talking about GTA VI, although it might come in there. It released today as of recording this. but the big thing that we are gonna be talking about is Xbox. Now, if you're not a gamer, you probably still know that there are three contenders out there. There's some other ones scattered in, but generally speaking, for consoles, we got Nintendo with the Switch lineup, we also have
Mikhail: Sony
Matt: with the PlayStation lineup, and then we have Microsoft with the Xbox lineup, and various consoles, slim versions, special versions, yada, yada, yada.
The list goes on. The thing is, is kind of off on its own, doing its own thing, and that's, that's great. So we have these two big titans kinda duking it out. We got Sony and Microsoft fighting, PlayStation versus Xbox, and Xbox has not been doing too well since the previous generation. So again, [00:01:00] just for the non-gamer out there, the previous generation was Xbox One and PlayStation 4, and the PlayStation 4 won in terms of sales. And then the next generation, which is the one we're on now, came around. That's the PlayStation 5, and it's winning on sales versus the Xbox Series, and there's two versions of that. There's the Series S, which is smaller and more affordable, and the Series X, which is the flagship full power, let's say, full computing power model. Now, there's also, again, some variants, the PS5 Pro, then they've, they've slimmed down the original PlayStation 5. The list goes on. There's all these nuances. That's not what we're here to, to discuss today, though. What we wanna discuss is our ideas, and yes, we are just, you know, kinda the armchair tech talkers, I guess, but we wanna discuss what we think Xbox needs to do in order to get more console sales, 'cause they are losing in terms of console sales. So Mike, I just kinda talked like crazy there. Why don't you give us your thoughts?
Mikhail: Yeah, [00:02:00] I think, coming at it from a kind of a different perspective, it's, it's not just about like, okay, let's get Xbox winning. Why do we want Xbox to win? I want to preface this with that conversation because a lot of what we're gonna be saying is gonna sound anti-consumer.
But the reason that I'm saying that is, is actually pro-consumer. If we have PlayStation alone, and we've seen this already, that's already been winning multiple generations, PlayStation 4 was a dominant win. PlayStation 5 is a... not just dominant, but like a complete destruction of, Xbox. Like, it almost has no competition.
That's how bad it is right now for Xbox. And because of that, we've already seen anti-consumer behavior by PlayStation because there's no one pushing them, so they can remove the disk drive, right? No one cares. they don't care personally. Like, obviously people care, but they don't care because what's Xbox gonna do?
They're probably gonna do the same thing 'cause they're following them. And they can make it so that their, you know, online services cost more. They've been continually [00:03:00] creeping up their online service costs. They can make it so their consoles cost more because, again, like, I mean, hardware costs more nowadays, but if there's no competition, they can just keep it up and up and up and up, and they can make it more, and they can, they can make more exclusives and stuff like that.
they have no reason to be pro-consumer when there's no one pushing them in the competition. And we're, we're seeing-
Matt: fighting. They need to be competing
Mikhail: Exactly. We- we're, we're already seeing this affect the consumer negatively. So what we're gonna be talking about here is, like, what Xbox needs to do, in our opinion, to win over some percentage share of the consumer and actually have a successful generation.
And I don't think they're gonna do what we're gonna be saying, personally. Like, I, I do think that they're gonna keep failing. I hope I'm wrong, because I want there to be these two behemoths at the, at the detriment to me in certain ways, because I'm probably not gonna buy both consoles every time.
Consoles are very expensive nowadays, and I just don't have the time. But I really want there to be the competition. And I'll start this off with the first thing, and the, and the probably the most [00:04:00] controversial one, is they need to bring back console exclusives,
Because Xbox has been going on this, like pro-consumer way of doing things and releasing all of their games on PC, and then all of a sudden also releasing all of their games on PS5, right? even their in-studio games are getting released on the PS5 a lot of the time, and if not, then just on the PC as well.
So there's less reason to buy an Xbox today than there was eight years ago. Not only that, there's just not any good Xbox games. I mean, there's decent ones, like Gears of War is a decent game, but it's not on the same level as what PlayStation has had in the past 10 years.
PlayStation has went on a dominant gaming streak with all their Naughty Dog exclusives, right? Insomniac exclusives. They've had a crap ton of really good exclusives. Now, they actually went the pro-consumer route as well of releasing those games on PC. I don't think they released them on [00:05:00] Xbox.
I can't remember. But they w- they did release some of their games on PC
Matt: one exclusion to that, that I can remember is, uh, Helldivers II
Mikhail: Yeah, fair enough. So the one, one, but they are, even they are going back to exclusives as far as I understand it now. Like, they're starting to backpedal on that because they're seeing it affect their sales. And yes, it's better for consumers to have options. I'm not saying that that's not the case.
But the reality is if we want really good games, PlayStation is incentivized to make really good console-selling games, quote unquote, by making it so that you buy a PlayStation to get that game. As soon as they lose that incentive, they're gonna start making worse games, in my opinion.
Okay? So I kind of am on the side of let's leave the console exclusives because I want there to be competition. And Xbox, back to the Xbox conversation, Xbox needs to up their games by a significant amount. They need their next Oblivion or their next Elder Scrolls game to be really [00:06:00] freaking good, and they need that game to be a console exclusive, and I'll let Matt kind of chime in here as well
Matt: Yeah, so there's a lot to unpack there. I mean, Sony/PlayStation was moving some of their games, reporting some of their games to PC. I believe that that program is completely ceased now.
Mikhail: mhmm
Matt: maybe there might be an, a, a, some sort of exclusion there or something that's already in progress, but as far as I know, I believe that they're backpedaling on the PC ports, at least for now, and they're gonna be more console exclusive like you mentioned. And the big thing here is PlayStation themselves have been struggling to make first-party titles. So, like, if you think back to the PS4, even dabbling into the PS3, you have these big franchises. You have your Uncharteds, you have your Ratchet & Clanks, you have your Last of Us, right? Well, there's only two of those, but you have your Last of Us and its, its remakes or, or redos, re-releases. You have your, Astro Bots now, right? You have these sort of, these big first-party games, and lately Sony has been really struggling because they've been [00:07:00] canceling projects left, right, and
Mikhail: mhmm
Matt: Concord, which was a complete game that completely crashed and burned, millions of dollars gone, lots of jobs lost, studio shut down, big mess. The thing is, is Sony is trying to get a games as a service game up. Now, if you don't know what that is, it's a game that is constantly ongoing, constantly up- updated, and players constantly pay. So something like Fortnite, Fortnite Battle Royale, and any of the modes that are within that. somebody can play Fortnite today and then play it in a year and it'll be completely different. You know, new maps or at the very least new POIs, certainly new seasons, new skins, et cetera. And so players can play for free, and if they want to start to, you know, start to get more into Fortnite, they can buy these battle passes, they can buy these skins, and they can buy into...
There's various game modes that you can actually make in Fortnite now that's like almost like an ecosystem of games. It's not just battle royale, it's not just Save the World, what, Fortnite was originally envisioned as. It's like this big smorgasbord, but it's constantly ongoing is the point, and players can constantly purchase new things.
There's [00:08:00] always new things to see. Sony's trying to get one of those up and running, but it's difficult because players only have limited time. If you're a person that's really into Fortnite, you're probably not really into Call of Duty. Call of Duty is a games as a service game as well. If you're really into Call of Duty, it's really time-consuming to finish that battle pass. If you, if you only have limited time, you're probably only gonna be a COD gamer or maybe a COD gamer and maybe you'll dabble in some single player stuff. You're not gonna dabble in multiple games as a service games, 'cause otherwise it's just every day you're logging in, doing your dailies. Every week you're logging in, doing your weeklies, and it's becoming like a chore unfortunately, right?
It's unfortunately gonna, gonna become more of that. So the thing here is, is Sony's trying to get one of those up and running to make money on a continual basis out of one license or one game. So now their first party games have been kind of falling off. We've
Mikhail: mhmm
Matt: Ghost of Yotei, things like this, but we are losing some now.
we're not getting as many as, as we were. what's kind of bided them [00:09:00] time to do this experiment and to do all these shutdowns and things is because the Xbox is not pushing them. The Xbox, like you mentioned, Mike, is not competing with them. Xbox is unfortunately not coming in and, and kind of pushing Sony and, kind of them and being like, "Hey, hey, hey, look, we have Gears of War, we have Halo, we have this, we have that, we have this.
Look at this, look at this, look at this," right? And it, you know, "They're only on Xbox, only on Xbox. Buy this on Xbox, buy this on Xbox," 'cause Xbox switched strategy. During the Xbox One era, Xbox switched strategy to almost like a Netflix of games. It's called Xbox Game Pass. You pay for... There's various tiers of it. Let's just say the Ultimate tier. That's what I have. You get online access, you get your... Which is like Xbox Live back in the day, but you get your online access, you get a library of games on the PC. You also get a library of games on the Xbox console. Again, there's multiple tiers. I'm talking about Ultimate. And then you also get some game streaming time as well, and you can stream to a phone or stream to a computer or whatever it is, and you can do that. And so that, that's more their model. They [00:10:00] still sell individual games physically. They still sell individual games on their Microsoft Store like normal.
But they're, they've moved to more this model where Game Pass is pushed, pushed, pushed, pushed, pushed.
thing is, though, is you could see that, like, is trying consumer-friendly things. Like, having a Netflix of games is a consumer-friendly thing. I've already mentioned they had two tiers of console. They have a Xbox Series S, a, a more affordable console, and then an Xbox Series X, a more flagship, more powerful console.
That's a consumer-friendly idea where you could get into the Xbox ecosystem for cheaper. And i- paying per month, yes, it adds up, but paying per month is something you could more easily budget for, and then you have this big library of games. And there's various tiers. You don't have to buy Ultimate. You can buy the lesser versions. And so there's all these tiers, and there's all these things that are, that Xbox is trying to do. Meanwhile, Sony is just like, "We'll put out the odd first-party game, but we'll just keep trying to get this games as a service up." Because Xbox is not really, pushing them, which [00:11:00] really sucks because what's basically happening here is even though Xbox is doing a bunch of consumer-friendly things, Xbox is unfortunately not really making any headway.
They don't seem to be, don't seem to be selling any, any consoles or not that many consoles in comparison to PlayStation. The thing here is if you wanna play Ratchet & Clank, you have to buy a PlayStation. You have to buy a PlayStation. You wanna... Or you can play it on PC, I guess now. But if you wanted to play it near launch, you had to buy a PlayStation. PC is kind of its own beast. Sony's not selling PCs. Microsoft is selling Surfaces, but the vast majority of PCs out there are not Surface models. So it's kind of its own beast. But in terms of the console wars, in terms of the console, you wanna play Ratchet & Clank, you wanna play Uncharted, you wanna play these big Sony titles, you have to pay for PlayStation and use it. Microsoft, because they started to falter in sales and because they started having issues, they started to make things multi-platform. the new Fable that's coming [00:12:00] out next year, that's gonna be on PlayStation day and date. There's a bunch of examples of this. Halo, that is an Xbox staple. Halo: Campaign Evolved, which is a remake of the original game, that game is on PlayStation. And Xbox games commonly did come out on both PlayStation and PC. That absolutely did happen. again, if we push the PC aside for a second, what's the reason to buy an Xbox? If you're a gamer, you only wanna buy one console, you look at it and you go, "Well, the only place where there's exclusive content is a PlayStation, and so I'm gonna buy that 'cause even if I don't wanna play the PlayStation games, I'll still get m- a majority of the Xbox games."
Now, boss has been put in place recently, Asha Sharma She has started to lock some things down, and there's two games that have been announced as Xbox exclusives. Gears of War: E-Day, very good game. That's a Xbox console exclusive, also available on the PC, but Xbox console exclusive. It's not on PlayStation. And then also [00:13:00] Clockwork Revolution be an Xbox console exclusive. But the problem here is, as Mike mentioned I think as well, consoles are now no longer cheap. I bought both a PlayStation and an Xbox. Together, Canadian dollars, not American dollars, Canadian dollars, was around 1,400 for both. Now we're looking at prices of, like, a thousand dollars apiece, if not more. Now, you can do some refurbs. There's gonna be some sales. There's gonna be some bundles 'cause these consoles aren't new, and so there's some wiggle room at retail. But due to the consumer electronics going up and up and up, it...
these things are no, no longer, like, all that accessible to buy two of them. I mean, heck, even the 1,400 was a lot. You know, what are people gonna say about a, like, 2,000 or 2,500? God knows what the next gen of consoles is gonna bring. So when you make a choice, You have to choose, "Okay, I want this one console." And Xbox has to have, in my opinion, it has to have good exclusives, as Mike has been saying. It has to have good exclusives, but it has to have console sellers. if it somehow made GTA VI a console exclusive, if it [00:14:00] somehow did that... I know Rockstar is not obviously gonna do that and, and hasn't, in fact. But if they somehow did that, people are going to buy Xboxes in order to play it. Starfield comes out, and Starfield's a big... Not Elder Scrolls, but it's by Bethesda. New IP from Bethesda in God knows how many years, right? Big, big news. Everyone's going crazy. And I did hear people that were getting into game streaming 'cause they did not wanna buy consoles.
They're buying Xbox Game Pass, which still supports Xbox, right? But, Starfield's on PlayStation now. And so all PlayStation had to do... I don't remember how long it, they had to wait, but all PlayStation had to do was wait for Starfield, and then now Starfield's on the PlayStation. they can play it whenever they whenever they want now.
And it's like, why would you ever buy an Xbox? have to have something that you can get nowhere else.
Mikhail: I honestly think if Starfield [00:15:00] came out of the gate and reviewed really, really well, even if it was a timed exclusive, I think it would've sold Xboxes. I think that it... The reason that it did not sell Xboxes was because it came out and flopped a little bit. It was very mid, right? Like, it wasn't a bad game.
Matt: it wasn't
Mikhail: It wasn't...
Matt: certainly
Mikhail: I think they need a revolutionary game. They need a GTA VI at 100% on Metacritic, and all the hype, and all the media attention that it's getting. They essentially, in my opinion, their only hope right now is, the Elder Scrolls game being on a higher level than Skyrim. It needs to be even better than Skyrim.
It needs to be reviewed better than Skyrim. It needs to bring Bethesda back into the conversation, and if that is an exclusive, even if it's a timed exclusive, I kind of agree with you that if it was a full, non-timed exclusive, I think it's gonna do better, but I think they're risking...
It's very risky on their parts to do that because we could be [00:16:00] wrong. Like, you and I could be very wrong. And then all that money that they've invested in Bethesda is gone, essentially. But if Bethesda comes out and it's like a... The, the next coming of Skyrim Plus Plus, and it is an exclusive, I think that is a console seller.
That, it will be a console seller. It has to, but it has to be that good. It cannot come out mid. It cannot
Matt: I agree with you that it can't come out mid, and I agree Elder Scrolls VI is, is a big enough title.
Mikhail: Yeah
Matt: know, it's... I don't know what, what, how it compares to GTA VI, but it is a big title,
Mikhail: Yeah, maybe not the same level, but it's big enough
Matt: It's big enough. It's certainly in the... Like, they're, they're both titans,
Mikhail: Correct.
Matt: They're both
Mikhail: Mm-hmm.
Matt: and they will sell consoles. The thing is, in my opinion, is like I think you almost need, because of the increased prices of the consoles, I think you actually need a portfolio of games. only
Mikhail: I
Matt: and I don't think anyone today is gonna buy a console for Gears of War [00:17:00] E-Day.
Gears of War E-Day is a fantastic Gears of War game. Really, really
Mikhail: C-correct.
Matt: last night,
Mikhail: Mm-hmm.
Matt: actually,
Mikhail: Mm-hmm
Matt: hours before GTA VI.
Mikhail: Well done
Matt: It was just... That was on the last part, so...
Mikhail: Mm-hmm.
Matt: But, um, it... Like G- like Gears of War E-Day, fantastic game. Is it gonna sell a $1,000 console, $700 console, $800 console, whatever it is in your jurisdiction? I don't think it is.
Mikhail: No
Matt: though, whenever I was talking about PlayStation, I didn't just say everyone's buying a PlayStation 'cause of Ratchet & Clank, everyone's buying a PlayStation 'cause of Astro Bot.
Mikhail: mhmm
Matt: their portfolio. Only a small subsection. Last of Us. Last of Us may be console seller. Still kind of a niche game, actually. Still a huge game, highly rated, but still kind of a niche game. Not a lot of people will
Mikhail: mhmm
Matt: a story game like that. Many people like multiplayer. Makes sense.
Mikhail: mhmm
Matt: I mean, Ratchet & Clank, friendly to more of a younger audience. Same with Astro Bot, right? Also a niche audience.
It seems like something like an Elder [00:18:00] Scrolls appeals to, let's say like teens and then as well in our 30s because we grew up with all the other Elder Scrolls games. So there's like such a wide appeal there. But my point is, I think you need to have a portfolio. So this is a good start.
Mikhail: You're right.
Matt: is a great start, 'cause people will play that.
Mikhail: Mm-hmm
Matt: Clockwork Revolution, assuming it, it turns out to be good, it looks cool. I don't... It... I haven't looked up anything else about it. I've just seen the odd
Mikhail: ya
Matt: Looks cool. But assuming it's good, that's great. I agree with you though, Mike, that you need to have some really big bangers at...
or at the very least you need to have volume. Now, There's a counterargument to this, to what I just said, and that is that had to just get rid of a, a bunch of studios, including the one that made Keeper, one of the things that Xbox was doing was they were trying to have these value adds to their subscription service, to Xbox Game Pass.
So they were having developers, indie developers, smaller developers, and larger developers just make games for the, catalog. The point is, is that just like [00:19:00] Netflix, third party games, things where Microsoft are not involved, they'll come and go. It's a rotating library. But something like Halo Infinite is in Xbox Game Pass.
You know it's gonna be there for an indefinite amount of time. And so they wanted things like Keeper, and they wanted this and that. The problem is, is people just look at it and go, "Oh, well, it's on the, it's on the subscription service. I'll go to it any time." You need to draw people in And I think that these extra little bits, Keeper is, is a good game, but Gears of War is a very good game. You have your Halos and everything. If you have a portfolio plus at least one banger like Elder Scrolls, it has to be very good, like you're saying, Mike, it has to review in the nines at least,
Mikhail: Yes
Matt: opinion. has to be loved by the community as well. you can do that, people will then buy Xboxes. And, and, and there is also a counter-argument to this as well. I've had friends that say, "Well, I only have a PlayStation." Like, you know, we're, we're past, we're past [00:20:00] having, a platform be an exclusive place to get things. Sony's doing it. Again, we're ignoring the PC for a moment. In terms of console market exclusively, Sony's freaking doing it with very few exclusions.
You're not gonna see Ratchet & Clank on Xbox anytime soon. gonna see that. You're not gonna see Astro Bot on Xbox Series X. You do see Helldivers, fine. have Destiny 2, fine. But they also inherited Destiny 2 'cause they bought it. They bought Bungie, and it's a whole thing. the... My, my point is, is, and I 100% agree with you, Mike, is that you need to have a banger, but I also think you need a portfolio. And, there's an example of this. Back in the PS3 days, the Xbox 360 largely won that
Mikhail: Mm-hmm.
Matt: You had
Mikhail: Yeah
Matt: and you had your Xbox 360, largely won, not completely. By the end, Sony started catching up, and I, I believe they may have actually surpassed or went on par with them at, by the end, and one of the reasons was the instant game collection.
It was Sony just kept working away at [00:21:00] first-party titles, and then it was like, "Hey, by the way, this console, the PS3, is kind of old right now, few years old at this point. If you buy this console," I don't know if there were any other stipulations. It's been a number of years. "But you get this thing called the instant game collection.
Look at all the games you get. So you buy this console, and look at all the games that you get with this console." And so it's like people start thinking like, "Oh my God, I get," whatever it is, the Sly Coopers, Resistance, whatever was in that collection. It's been so many years now for me. But the point is, look at this instant collection, and there's, there's definitely a couple bangers in there.
But like, oh man, like think about gift time. "Oh, I'm gonna... You know, it's Christmas. The kid wants a console. I don't really wanna buy games. I'll buy this thing, and it comes with an instant game collection." there's that value add there. And, and so it's a combination of the value add, Xbox is already trying with Game Pass as well as
Mikhail: Yeah
Matt: various levels of console, but you need to [00:22:00] have the formula. You need to have this is only on Xbox. You can only play this here. if you want to play this, you have to play this here. I think putting Fable on PlayStation's a mistake, and I know that I have friends that will absolutely disagree with that saying, you know, we're, we're past that. But I don't see Ghost of Yotei on Xbox
Mikhail: in this one web news we're very aligned on this stuff. Like we're, we're completely aligned. On the more controversial side, in my opinion, like I think that this is a controversial take, for a couple different reasons. But like, I think Fable should be a console exclusive.
I agree with you that there needs to be a catalog of games. It can't just be one game, for sure. and Xbox has the studios to do that. That's the weird thing is like
Matt: ya
Mikhail: they... The, a crazy take and a, the take that I think would kill, would kill me is Call of Duty should be Xbox exclusive. Now, it can't be right now,
Matt: There
Mikhail: obviously.
Matt: crap. There was a whole
Mikhail: Yes.
Matt: yeah
Mikhail: But it sh- it sh- they should absolutely have the [00:23:00] path to making it a console exclusive. Like once... It's, it's something that they dangle. It's something like, "Hey, Xbo-" And I think they even did that when they first bought Ca- uh, uh, Call of Duty. They even said that there's a potential of this being a console exclusive, so they just need to bring it back up.
Matt: I
Mikhail: I believe that-
Matt: I don't recall that, but I do remember there being a lot of chatter. Like, there was a lot of
Mikhail: Yeah
Matt: it, it has to be here. Oh, no, we'll make it on Switch. Don't worry, it'll be everywhere." There was a lot of chatter
Mikhail: And I understand the logic behind it because it sells more copies of the game, and at the end of the day, the game is gonna make more money than the consoles, I think. As far as I understand, the consoles is just the driving path to sell games, and that's why Xbox went the route of just putting it everywhere, 'cause they want to sell their games more.
But that didn't work. It just didn't work. And, and I think you need to go back to the model of the console actually bringing you income and also selling the games because of the ga- console exclusive. So regardless, they have a lot of levers to pull that they could create a good catalog of [00:24:00] games. They could have multiple bangers in the...
Especially, like, you have-- If Elder Scrolls comes out as a banger, and then you have, like, two or three more that you've announced that could be bangers, and you have the, whatever the one you mentioned, maybe that becomes a great first-party, a new first-party title, right? Like a new, a new one. You need cou- you need a couple of those too.
Matt: Oh, uh,
Mikhail: new. A
Matt: you're
Mikhail: Clockwork Revolution. Like, you need a couple of those, something completely new that all of a sudden-- that surprises people. You want that surprise factor. So if you have, like, five, six of those all lined up, and you start all, all of a sudden becoming exclusive, yeah, it-- I think, I think Xbox has a good chance to come back in that scenario.
A very good chance. 'Cause the hard-hardware-wise, arguably, they're better than PS5.
Matt: yeah. I,
Mikhail: Yeah
Matt: VI on my Xbox. I love my Xbox. I use my Xbox more than my, PlayStation 5, I mostly use my PlayStation 5 for multiplayer games, mostly
Mikhail: Exactly. So like Xbox is a better piece of hardware, and they could continue to [00:25:00] be a better piece of hardware than PlayStation. And if they just execute on the exclusives, I really think that that's the missing piece. Like that is the thing that they stopped doing and potentially killed them. that and just not making great games.
But even if they made amazing games and they, but they released them on PlayStation, it, it just like, yes, the games would sell well probably, and they would make a bunch of money, but then they would just kill off the Xbox. And I don't want the, I don't want the Xbox to die,
Matt: No, we don't want the Xbox to die
Mikhail: Yeah.
Matt: I do
Mikhail: Yeah
Matt: have... One thing I, that we're not aligned on, I do think Call of Duty should be multi-platform. Now, the reason... Now, and I'll, I'll give you, I'll
Mikhail: Yeah
Matt: though. Because something like Helldivers should also be multi-platform. I think that if you have a
Mikhail: Sure
Matt: as a service game that is multiplayer, the, the goal of a games as a service game is not the initial sales of that game. In fact, sometimes it's free upfront. I think that you want to actually extract money, figuratively speaking, or I guess almost literally I guess,
Mikhail: Literally, yeah
Matt: Sony themselves aren't necessarily paying that, but you want the Sony install base [00:26:00] to pay you even though they're competing with you. Because also you're looking at the health of the game as well. It's something that happens with many games where, something like a, let's say like a Battlefield. Battlefield will add like 50 game modes. Even though there's a healthy population of people, they don't have the population of people to fill all those game modes.
They've split the player base too much.
Mikhail: Mm-hmm
Matt: And so what ends up happening is I think it's... I, man, I play a lot of games. I think it's like Battlefield 2142, I think. The one that got really bad reviews. that game had a rotating, later on in its life, had a rotating set of game modes. At the very least, a rotating set of game modes on the homepage.
Mikhail: Mm-hmm.
Matt: didn't play that one very of- very often. But the point is, the reason why they limit the game modes and rotate the game modes is because they don't want to have like 15 game modes. They want to have maybe 5 available at any one time, so the player base can still have some options, but it's only split among five, five game modes. Appl- You can apply that to hardware as [00:27:00] well though, because if you're like, "Hey, Call of Duty is only on Xbox," now you've just split the player base again where it's like now literally some people have a PlayStation for The Last of Us III or whatever comes out, right, down the line, or maybe they want to play all the old PlayStation games. So now, they're locked and they're like, "Well, now I can't play Call of Duty." But meanwhile, they, they could have been a revenue source. So I will say, like games as a service I do think is different personally
Mikhail: I think you're absolutely right from a business perspective. that's how it should be, honestly, like if you wanna make the most money. I think my idea was a more selfish idea of like I want Xbox to survive and I think temp- even temporarily, just like even one Call of Duty game, they hype it up like crazy and they release it only on Xbox during this time of, like, all the other bangers that they have lined up, right?
Like, during their, their push to bring Xbox back to being relevant, they just do that. And yeah, they're gonna catch a [00:28:00] lot of flak and they're gonna... There's gonna be a bunch of media around it, but like even... That might not be even a bad thing for them at that time. 'Cause we, we know that gamers like to cry and cry and cry, but they'll still buy stuff.
Like, that's just how it's been proven time and time again, that the louder the gamers cry, the more likely that thing is gonna succeed,
Matt: There's often
Mikhail: that they're crying against.
Matt: a
Mikhail: Correct.
Matt: me,
Mikhail: loud minority.
Matt: issues for sure
Mikhail: very much so. So like as soon as you have that loud minority, you're like, "Oh, that means we're onto something."
as like a game studio, I almost think that they think that, because it seems to be true. And, I just want Xbox to succeed because I want PlayStation to have pushback. I'm a PlayStation guy, to be clear. I've owned every PlayStation since PS1.
not every variation, let me be clear, like just one of each. Like I don't have, you know, a PS2, PS2 slim, PS2 mi- like there's like a billion different variations of each one. I have one of each, one of each, usually the base models. and I plan on keeping that unless Sony just keeps kind of being a dick and g- going back on, on [00:29:00] consumerism and becoming worse and worse, and their games become worse and worse, like Matt and I were talking about.
Then I hope that Xbox is gonna be competitive at that time and I can switch, like-
Matt: Well, the thing you and I were talking about to talk about Play- Sony, uh, single player game quality, I don't think the actual quality in terms of QA and stuff has gone
Mikhail: mhmm
Matt: but I'm a big fan of Spider-Man. Played the first Spider-Man, I played Miles Morales and really liked them, and then I went and played Spider-Man 2.
The actual Spider-Man segments are great. They're all great and everything. But I am so sick, and I've talked about this a bunch on my gaming podcast, Day One Patch Podcast, go check it out. I've talked about it a bunch on there where I, I just, I don't need these, these slow down areas. Like the, the formula of, of, you know, action sequence, slow time, action sequence, slow time.
It's like I don't need to go on a date with Mary Jane. I could see it in a, in, in a cut scene. I d- I, the player, do- don't have to control me walking around an amusement park. I don't need to go on an emotional [00:30:00] bike ride with Harry. I just don't need to do it. I don't need to do that,
I first started seeing it in The Last of Us, which is PS3, and so I just think that the formula is getting old to the point where I really liked the Spider-Man segments of playing when I was Spider-Man, playing Spider-Man 2. But these slow segments and these like transitionary segments from action sequence to action sequence, I just, I'm bored of that formula. and the freaking phone calls. Like people in games are c-
Mikhail: Yeah
Matt: not just a Sony thing. You can't keep calling me up. You know, it's real bad. GTA, there's a freaking Instagram in the game. There's an Instagram clone, and so, and, and you can s- you can literally doom scroll in
Mikhail: Oh, God
Matt: are calling me and texting me, and I was texting and driving and crashed
Mikhail: That's amazing though. That is actually an amazing... I gotta play, I gotta play GTA. That's, that is, it has to happen. I might, I m- I might, I might stay up all night. Yeah.
Matt: just boom, like right into a ditch. I was like,
Mikhail: Mm-hmm
Matt: eh?" Yeah, [00:31:00] Mike, you... I
Mikhail: Yeah.
Matt: your impressions on or off air
Mikhail: Yeah
Matt: VI,
Mikhail: I'm gonna try to g- I'm gonna try to get some gaming in
Matt: Like you said, you're gonna no- you're gonna all-night it just
Mikhail: I'm gonna try, yeah. I'm, I'm already not sleeping 'cause my daughter's not sleeping. like just wakes up randomly. So I might as well just like take advantage of that and wait for her to wake up, and while I'm waiting, just grind GTA on my PS Portal
Matt: I like how you're gonna stream it too. You have the whole PlayStation line up there, yet you're, you're not just
Mikhail: I have the whole, I have, I have everything. I could show you, like I have everything here. Like all the, all the mobile, all the, again, one of each console for their hardware, like the big consoles and their mobile consoles, like their,
Matt: Yeah
Mikhail: I, I plan on keeping that. So whenever the new PlayStation, I think, I think the...
It's rumored to be a portable device, one of the new PlayStations. Like, I think they, they're gonna release like tandem devices, PlayStation 6 and a portable version, or it might be like a combination.
Matt: version of the PlayStation
Mikhail: That's what I want, yeah.
Matt: of the PlayStation 6
Mikhail: Yeah, [00:32:00] that's... If, if they have good games, like I'm gonna be clear, I'm not gonna just like blindly go into it, but so far PlayStation has been pretty good.
If they have good games, I'm probably gonna be buying that. Maybe not day one, but at some point.
Matt: Yeah.
Mikhail: I'm a PlayStation guy.
Matt: that's our thoughts. I don't know if you had anything else to add or if, uh, i- if we wanna continue the conversation at all, but, like, that's our thoughts I think on Xbox and
Mikhail: want you come, come after us, by the way. I hope, I hope people like... 'Cause, 'cause again, I understand the controversial take here. I get, I get your side, the people coming after us, but still flame us, destroy us, HTML everything on X, HTML all the things on Instagram, Twitter, and YouTube, and all that stuff
Matt: I encourage constructive discussion.
Mikhail: Nope.
Matt: I'm gonna say for the record, me, Matt Lawrence, I want constructive criticism. I'm down to talk about and debate gaming things, including if you think that games should no longer be exclusive, I'm, I'm down to, to have that discussion. [00:33:00] I do not want death threats. I do not want aggression. I just wanna have a good debate.
I don't
Mikhail: It's fine.
Matt: as a consumer to, to want games to not be exclusive. It'd be nice to
Mikhail: Yeah
Matt: access to software everywhere. However, I think it's dumb from Microsoft's perspective to not have Xbox exclusive games if they wanna sell their box, if they wanna sell that console
Mikhail: slight disagreement there with you, 'cause I do think it's a little bit dumb for a consumer to do it at the behest of a company going downhill. if, if we lose a main competitor in a two-competitor space, 'cause the Switch isn't really a competitor. I consider this to be a two, a two-console race war.
Matt: two
Mikhail: If we...
Matt: fighting
Mikhail: Yeah, if, if, if we lose a competitor at the behest of it being exclusive, like, games being non-exclusive, that, in my opinion, is not the right move for a consumer at a consumer side. Again, this is my opinion, and I think that a pro-consumer move would be to [00:34:00] make sure that the other, the other competitor is healthy and fighting the, the, the main incumbent.
Matt: I would say that they could potentially lose next gen and still survive, assuming they're a decent competitor. If it's like Sony's first but they're a close second, if Xbox is a
Mikhail: yeah, yeah, that's fine
Matt: then fine. But... And, they have to kinda like force each other competitive-wise to, to
Mikhail: mhmm
Matt: and, and make some small things.
And I mean, I guess PlayStation Plus has added almost like a Game Pass-like service probably
Mikhail: They have
Matt: Game Pass, but it's not as fully serviced, let's say. There's not day one games and things like that oftentimes going inside of the PlayStation service, whereas the Xbox service seems to be based around that, especially the, Ultimate Tier.
Mikhail: Mm-hmm. Yeah.
Matt: I,
Mikhail: I like Game Pass. I think Game Pass was a good idea, it's just they should've kept exclusives. I don't see the reason why they didn't keep exclusives. I don't understand that logic
Matt: need exclusives, and I'm on the fence about [00:35:00] Game Pass. I mean, I think it's a good deal for me. I'm saving money. I... reason why I'm on the fence is I now look at a game and go, "Wow, I don't really wanna pay for that," and then I don't. So is it devaluing games for me?
Mikhail: Maybe. Oh, yeah, that's a whole other conversation. Let, let, let's leave that one to another one. Yeah, yeah, I agree with you there. Like, there is, there is a debate to be had there, for sure
Matt: Yeah, absolutely. But anyway, Constructive feedback, DMs, messages, and conversations only, please. but I'd love to talk about it because gaming's in a weird spot, consumer electronics are in a weird spot, and, we've said our piece. That's the web news for this week. Hope you enjoyed it. Thanks for hanging out.
Mikhail: Bye